Post by Null on Aug 10, 2007 15:42:29 GMT
alright, so I've told him some of the things I'm posting here, and he of course wants the isle, so its gone to his diplomates. Here are the points he sent me, that he's provided to them.
1. I cleared the isle
2. I first took the isle
3. You sent cats against a 5pt isle with a level 1 house.
4. You did not respond to my emails or even read them after you took the isle though I sent them before you would have started building the main house.
5. I attempted to retake the isle due to your lack of response and failed.
6. Fred-n-Fred took the isle because in my attempt to retake it the house was at level 1.
7. I supplied Fred-n-Fred with supplies to help him keep the isle.
8. Fred-n-Fred renouces claim
9. I write you and offer you .5 colony ship in compensation if you allow me to take isle without dispute even though your sending cats voids my alliance requirement to do that.
10. You are angered by the statement that I am moving on the isle.
11. I retook the isle and stocked it with stonies.
The later points are more for timeline purposes if this gets resolved by others."
Here are my points
1. He claims to have cleared 100 SMS from the isle...inconsequential in my view
2. Agreed
3. I sent the cats, as a 5pt house *could* have up to a lvl6 MH, and once again, the cats did not touch the MH, as it was still at lvl 1 when I colo'd
4. He sent the mails while I was asleep, the main house was built up after I colo'd because it was already queued up when I took it.
5. see above
6. HE cat'd the house back down to lvl1 before his re-colo attempt from #5. (attack reports available)
7. ok
8. Agreed
9. Agreed (he offered it)
10. He mails me in the morning to start a discussion, claiming his points on why it should be his isle. Then 30minutes later, sends another message that he has a colo attempt inbound on the isle. I was/am very angered by the "its mine so I'll take it regardless" attitude
11. see above (I wasn't aware he has already stoner dropped it until now)
If a diplo could please have a look, I'd appreciate it. If you feel I've got no case, then thats fine, I'll gladly go with whatever decision comes of it. I just hate how he has gone about things once this dispute arose, and I believe its a reflection of Pantheon and their attitude these days.
1. I cleared the isle
2. I first took the isle
3. You sent cats against a 5pt isle with a level 1 house.
4. You did not respond to my emails or even read them after you took the isle though I sent them before you would have started building the main house.
5. I attempted to retake the isle due to your lack of response and failed.
6. Fred-n-Fred took the isle because in my attempt to retake it the house was at level 1.
7. I supplied Fred-n-Fred with supplies to help him keep the isle.
8. Fred-n-Fred renouces claim
9. I write you and offer you .5 colony ship in compensation if you allow me to take isle without dispute even though your sending cats voids my alliance requirement to do that.
10. You are angered by the statement that I am moving on the isle.
11. I retook the isle and stocked it with stonies.
The later points are more for timeline purposes if this gets resolved by others."
Here are my points
1. He claims to have cleared 100 SMS from the isle...inconsequential in my view
2. Agreed
3. I sent the cats, as a 5pt house *could* have up to a lvl6 MH, and once again, the cats did not touch the MH, as it was still at lvl 1 when I colo'd
4. He sent the mails while I was asleep, the main house was built up after I colo'd because it was already queued up when I took it.
5. see above
6. HE cat'd the house back down to lvl1 before his re-colo attempt from #5. (attack reports available)
7. ok
8. Agreed
9. Agreed (he offered it)
10. He mails me in the morning to start a discussion, claiming his points on why it should be his isle. Then 30minutes later, sends another message that he has a colo attempt inbound on the isle. I was/am very angered by the "its mine so I'll take it regardless" attitude
11. see above (I wasn't aware he has already stoner dropped it until now)
If a diplo could please have a look, I'd appreciate it. If you feel I've got no case, then thats fine, I'll gladly go with whatever decision comes of it. I just hate how he has gone about things once this dispute arose, and I believe its a reflection of Pantheon and their attitude these days.