Colonisation dispute: {11:93:8}

[DrieZ/Cesium]

Hello, I'll start this thread asap, because Cesium isn't online atm, but to come to the facts:

Cesium has taken the island 11:93:8 , an unruled island untill yesterday. But some guy from Pantheon named nightstar had cleared the island with heavy losses.

Since the island was only just an hour or 2 our of my core islands, it was very tempting to take the island. As I spied the island, I saw almost no damage to stonewall (lvl17) and the mainhouse (lvl19), but with no troops on it.
I though, maybe the guy built up his island like this, but could'nt find an explanation but that the island had been cleared by somebody.

I took the island over 10 hours before nightstars colofleet would land. He had also sent a clearing fleet to knock down the main house, but in the end the colonisation attempt bounced.

i'm offering this guy a huge compensation of gold or cats (still to come to an agreement between DrieZ and Cesium, both manager of the Cesium account)

[2kcastle]

This guys taken heavy losses to clear that isle :

Cesium
10 hours ago
yeh he showed me some reports

around 300 lws lost

---

This shouldnt be a colo dispute at all, If one of us spent 300 lws plus troops clearing an isle theres no way we'd let someone else take it.
If his reports look genuine which i assume they do then i cant see the problem.
We extend the same courtesy to [pantheon] that we'd expect them to show us and you let him take the isle back.

[AeroS]

Cesium asked that I find out if Nightstar woudl be willing to take compensation of any kind.
So we are now waiting to see what that reply will be. If Nightstar is unwilling to be compensated then I think there is no choice but to relinquish the island and take half a colo ship as comp for Cesium. This has been our standard operating procedure so I assume it applies here as well. I should be able to post Nightstars response to Cesiums request inthe next 12 hours.

[SkulkrinBait]

As long as he gets compensated for his colo ship then he should give the island back.

[AeroS]

Deadlock
4 minutes ago
RE: nightstar
He wants the island, he took the time to clear it and wants the rewards of having the island.

Will Cesium take 30kgold/30lumber to let nightstar retake the isle?

He wants the island. He offers full price of your colo ship. I will be out for 1 hour and then I would like to put this issue to bed. let me know what you want me to tell them.