Post by 2kcastle on Aug 11, 2007 17:09:50 GMT
I'd like to suggest this as an official policy.
For 1 pointers and undeveloped isles :
The only claim to any new isle is the main house built to lvl 2.
If someone takes the isle while the main house is lvl 1 and they haven't sent cats then ownership passes to them.
If the main house reaches lvl 2 and someone sends a catapult fleet against it, then its an aggressive act and the original owner still has the right to the isle and should have the isle returned to them plus compensation for the colo ship needed to re-claim it.
For developed isles :
Ownership is determined based on who expended the most troops and ships to secure the isle.
In the event of two or more people clearing an isle the person who cleared the most ( not who lost the most of their own fleet while clearing it ) would have the greatest claim to an isle.
If the party(s) who helped with the clearing have lost what is thought to be a large amount ( probably best decided on an individual basis by the alliance ) while clearing, Then as a gesture of goodwill they would be entitled to compensation.
Sniping of isles ( deliberately waiting for someone to clear the defences and then trying to colo ) is never permitted and is seen as an aggressive act.
Obviously i know that attack/spy reports can be faked so anyone found to have altered or fabricated reports to support their claim to an isle immediately forfeits any rights.
For 1 pointers and undeveloped isles :
The only claim to any new isle is the main house built to lvl 2.
If someone takes the isle while the main house is lvl 1 and they haven't sent cats then ownership passes to them.
If the main house reaches lvl 2 and someone sends a catapult fleet against it, then its an aggressive act and the original owner still has the right to the isle and should have the isle returned to them plus compensation for the colo ship needed to re-claim it.
For developed isles :
Ownership is determined based on who expended the most troops and ships to secure the isle.
In the event of two or more people clearing an isle the person who cleared the most ( not who lost the most of their own fleet while clearing it ) would have the greatest claim to an isle.
If the party(s) who helped with the clearing have lost what is thought to be a large amount ( probably best decided on an individual basis by the alliance ) while clearing, Then as a gesture of goodwill they would be entitled to compensation.
Sniping of isles ( deliberately waiting for someone to clear the defences and then trying to colo ) is never permitted and is seen as an aggressive act.
Obviously i know that attack/spy reports can be faked so anyone found to have altered or fabricated reports to support their claim to an isle immediately forfeits any rights.
